Why Your Newsletter Isn’t Growing (And What to Do About It)

Let me guess: you’ve got the writing chops, your ideas are solid, and you’re showing up consistently… but the growth?

Not so much.

It’s frustrating, isn’t it?

You’re not alone—this is where most newsletters stall.

Here’s the thing: great content isn’t enough.

The secret sauce lies in making it easy and exciting for readers to connect with you.

That’s what this guide is about: bridging the gap between “I have a Newsletter” and “I have a thriving Newsletter community.”

Let’s dive into two key strategies to supercharge your Newsletter. (from now on I’ll refer to Substack as I believe it’s the best way to grow)

Before we start Newsletters aren’t the only way to monetise your writing…

Monetising Your Writing – Adopt A No Pressure Value First Approach by Mark Thompson

Build an Income with your writing without creating constant offers

Read on Substack

1. Nail the Perfect Welcome Email

Your welcome email is your chance to shine.

It’s like your newsletter’s opening act—a little pizzazz here can go a long way.

Think of your welcome email as a handshake, firm, warm, and memorable.

Tell your readers who you are, why they’ll love your newsletter, and what they’ll get next.

People love GIFs, emojis, and a dash of humor.

Open with a friendly wave emoji (👋) or a fun GIF that says, “I see you!”

👉 Use emojis as signposts to highlight key points.

Match the tone to your brand.

Financial writer? Keep it classy.

Running a pop culture blog? Go wild with memes!

Nobody likes feeling like they’re part of a bulk send.

Use your subscriber’s name or a casual nickname.

Share a snippet about your journey—why you started this newsletter and what excites you about it.

End with a question or invite replies.

It boosts engagement and keeps your emails out of spam folders.

Set clear expectations upfront.

Let readers know how often you’ll send emails, what topics you’ll cover, and if there are “must-read” posts or series. Link to them!

2. Embed a Subscription Form on Your Website

Let’s make it effortless for people to subscribe without leaving your website.

Head to substackapi.com.

It’s a free, simple tool to generate customized subscription forms.

Match it to your website’s design by choosing colors, fonts, and placeholders that blend seamlessly. Preview the form to see how it looks.

Copy the generated code and paste it where you want the form to appear—on your homepage, blog posts, or landing page.

If you want advanced features like analytics or design tweaks, SubstackAPI offers a paid version, but the free version is plenty powerful.

Your Next Move

Don’t let your Newsletter growth plateau.

A killer welcome email and a seamless signup process are small tweaks that deliver big results.

The sooner you implement these strategies, the sooner you’ll stop wondering “Why isn’t my Newsletter  growing?” and start seeing real traction.

Got questions or ideas?

Hit reply—I’d love to hear from you!

Leave a Comment